American Pyramid
  • Home
  • Standings
    • Regional Leagues >
      • Gulf Coast Premier League
      • Northeast Elite Soccer League
    • East Region >
      • Connecticut >
        • Amateur Soccer League of CT
        • Connecticut Adult Soccer League
        • Connecticut Soccer League
        • Shoreline Adult Soccer League
        • Southern New England Adult Soccer League
      • Maryland >
        • Maryland Major Soccer League
        • Mason-Dixon Soccer League
        • Washington Premier League
      • Massachusetts >
        • Bay State Soccer League
        • EMWSL
        • FA 1
        • Mass State Soccer League
        • USAfrica Soccer League
      • New Hampshire >
        • New Hampshire Soccer Conference
      • New Jersey >
        • Garden State Soccer League
        • Medford Soccer Association
        • North Jersey Soccer League
      • New York >
        • Buffalo District Soccer League
        • Caribbean Cup Soccer
        • Central New York State Soccer League
        • Cosmopolitan Soccer League
        • Eastern District Soccer League
        • Long Island Soccer Football League
        • Rochester District Soccer League
        • Syracuse Soccer Association
      • Pennsylvania >
        • American Soccer League
        • Capital Area Soccer League
        • Casa Soccer League
        • Erie Soccer League
        • Harrisburg Area Women's Soccer League
        • PA West Adult Soccer
        • Philadelphia Premier Soccer League
        • USL - Pennsylvania
      • Vermont >
        • Vermont Amateur Soccer League
      • Virginia >
        • Commonwealth Soccer League
        • CVA Soccer
        • Northern Virginia Adult Soccer Association
        • Richmond Adult Soccer Association
        • Soccer Organization Charlottesville Area
    • South Region >
      • Alabama >
        • Southern Alabama Soccer Association
      • Florida >
        • APSL
        • Beaches Adult Soccer League
        • Coral Springs Men's Soccer League
        • Central Florida Soccer League
        • Florida Suncoast Soccer League
        • Gold Coast Soccer Premier League
        • Lakeland Adult Soccer Association
        • Miami Soccer League
        • NE Florida Soccer League
        • South Florida Leagues
        • Spring Gulf Coast
      • Georgia >
        • Atlanta District Adult Soccer League
      • Kentucky >
        • Mockingbird Soccer
      • North Carolina >
        • ABASA
      • Tennessee >
        • Middle Tennessee Soccer Alliance
      • Texas >
        • Austin Men's Soccer Association
        • Fort Worth Premier League
        • North Texas Premier Soccer Association
        • Texas Collegiate Soccer League
    • Midwest Region >
      • Illinois >
        • Central Illinois Soccer League
        • CLASA Soccer League
        • Metropolitan Soccer League
        • National Soccer League of Chicago
        • Premier Soccer League Chicagoland
        • Tri-County Soccer League
      • Kansas >
        • Emporia Soccer League
        • KCK Soccer League
        • Lawrence Adult Soccer League
      • Michigan >
        • Blossomland Soccer League
        • Michigan Premier Soccer League
        • Michigan United Soccer League
      • Minnesota >
        • Duluth Amateur Soccer League
        • Minnesota Adult Soccer League
        • Minnesota Recreational Soccer League
        • Southern Minnesota Adult Soccer League
      • Ohio >
        • Cincinnati Premier League
        • Columbus Premier League
        • Dayton Amateur Soccer League
        • Lake Erie Soccer League
        • Northeast Ohio Amateur Soccer Association
      • Wisconsin >
        • Northern Wisconsin Soccer League
        • Wisconsin Soccer Leagues
    • West Region >
      • Arizona >
        • Arizona Champions League
        • State United Amateur Soccer League
      • California >
        • California International Soccer Club
        • NorCal Leagues >
          • Liga Eastbay
          • Liga South Bay
          • Liga Valley
        • Peninsula Soccer League
        • San Francisco Soccer Football League
        • So Cal Premier
        • South Bay Sports
      • Colorado >
        • Colorado Premier League
      • Hawaii >
        • Major Island Soccer Association >
          • Division 1
          • Division 2
          • Division 3
      • Montana >
        • Bozeman Adult Soccer League
        • Helena Adult Soccer Association
      • New Mexico >
        • Albuquerque Soccer League
        • Mesilla Valley Soccer League
        • Santa Fe Adult Soccer League
      • Oregon >
        • Greater Portland Soccer District
        • Oregon Premier League
        • Southern Oregon Adult Soccer
      • Utah >
        • Greater Salt Lake Soccer League
        • Premier Club Soccer League
      • Washington >
        • Evergreen Premier League
        • Greater Seattle Soccer League
        • Snohomish County Adult Soccer League
        • Western Washington Premier League
    • National Leagues >
      • National Premier Soccer League
      • Premier Development League
      • United Premier Soccer League
  • Patreon
  • Patrons
  • The Network
    • Politithink
    • Ramble Sport
  • Contact AP

One League To Rule Them All?

12/15/2015

Comments

 
Picture
Picture
Hello readers, I wanted to begin by apologizing for the long wait on this article. For those of you who might not know, several weeks ago, or should I say, Thanksgiving weekend, I threw out the idea of doing an article on the pros, cons, and cost of an amateur team joining a regional league over a national league. I make no promises as to how long or short this article might be, and I will do my best to be as fair and un-biased as possible. Check out the article after the break.
Now, before we go any further, I want to go ahead and get some of my biases out in the open so I can, hopefully, get them out of the way of the rest of the article. Fair and balanced, that's how we like to be.

Bias Number 1: I prefer regional leagues. In my research, I've found them to be cheaper in every way. Lower entry fees, lower yearly fees, less travel because teams are closer to each other. Regional leagues also have the ability to tap into regional pride on a macro level, pitting teams from certain areas of the country to determine who's the best. National leagues tap into this on a more micro level. 'Yay, you're best in your region. But are you best in the country?' 

Bias Number 2: Personally, I believe regional leagues are the key to the growth of the game in the US. They can foster competition and investment in the game in specific areas of the country, allowing small cities, towns, and even neighborhoods an opportunity to play the game and help players grow.

Alright, with those two big biases out of the way, lets get rolling. The first thing I want to do is give a cost breakdown of the two primary national leagues, the National Premier Soccer League and the Premier Development League. Now, I haven't been able to get exact data for everything, and anything I can't verify through my sources will be marked with an * to help provide full disclosure.
Picture
National Premier Soccer League
Entry Fee: $12,500
Yearly Fee: $5,000
​Number of Teams: 81* (Unconfirmed Hiatus Teams)
Weakest Region: Pacific Northwest
​Strongest Region: Midwest/Great Lakes
Picture
Premier Development League
Entry Fee: $75,000
​Yearly Fee: $10,000*
Number of Teams: 59 US, 6 Canadian
​Weakest Region: Pacific Northwest
Strongest Region: Mid Atlantic
Several things really pop out once you look at these numbers, some good, some bad. 
  1. NPSL has a lot of teams. Odds are pretty good that if you're looking into starting a team, they've got one fairly close by
  2. PDL is rather expensive for an amateur league. Add some of the other options they have for supporting their teams, and you're $100,000 in the hole pretty quick. 
  3. If you're in the Pacific Northwest, don't join these leagues. Between the two leagues there are 5 US based teams. This area boasts several strong Regional leagues. The Evergreen Premier League, Oregon Premier League, and the Pacific Coast League for Canada. Go local here.
  4. Both leagues have areas of serious strength. NPSL dominates the Great Lakes, while PDL has a firm grip on the Mid Atlantic. Looking into starting a team in those areas? Both leagues are viable
  5. Each league has a strong California presence. But California has plenty of options as well. Locally they have the Nor-Cal and So-Cal Premier Leagues, the Coast Soccer League, and regionally they have the United Premier Soccer League, running teams in Cali, Arizona and Nevada. You are spoiled for choice on the West Coast.
Now, lets look at the newcomer to the scene, the Premier League of America, formerly the Great Lakes Premier League. Founded last year as a regional league, they gained enough exposure in one year that they were receiving inquiries from well outside their region. Keeping their regional league fees in place, they are now looking to expand nationally, and are not afraid to have multiple teams in the same city. Milwaukee already has 2 for 2016.

Premier League of America
Yearly Cost: $2,000
Annual Fee: $1,000


Obviously these guys are newcomers to the scene, but they have the lowest cost of any of what I would consider to be professionally run National Amateur Leagues. They have already started to get some NPSL teams to switch leagues, including one of the founding NPSL teams, Madison 56ers. 

Sad as it might be to see such a well run regional league go national after year, they will be worth keeping an eye on as their expansion teams spiral out from the Great Lakes. With such manageable costs, it's going to be much easier for neighborhood and small community teams to move up to bigger playing field. Take the PLA's newest team, Carpathia FC, as an example. They are an old Michigan team, located in Sterling Heights, that will be playing on a bigger stage for the first time ever. As a bonus, Oakland United is in Rochester Hills, right next door. These are the kind of teams and rivalries the PLA is designed to facilitate.

Now, each league has some pretty obvious pros and cons, that I'll address below. 
NPSL
Pros
  1. Lots of teams
  2. Reasonable cost
  3. Rapid growth
Cons
  1. High team turnover
  2. Low bar for entry
  3. Slow to update info
PDL
Pros
  1. Good number of teams
  2. Low team turnover
  3. Known quantity
Cons
  1. High cost
  2. More scattered teams
  3. Some Canadian travel
PLA
Pros
  1. Lowest Cost
  2. Intentional Regional Focus
  3. Slow and steady growth
Cons
  1. Unknown quantity
  2. Only in Great Lakes
  3. Lots of growing pains ahead
As you can see, every league has good things, every league has bad things. There are plenty of teams that don't play regionally because their players won't be presented on a larger stage. But that is no reason to dismiss regional leagues if you are looking to starting a team. For the second year in a row, the Evergreen Premier League has had a player receive an invite to the MLS combine. You don't have to play nationally to be know nationally. You just need to play well. And there is no reason for your team to not be know nationally either. The biggest issue facing amateur teams on local and national levels is, quite simply, branding. If you brand your team poorly and don't treat it like a big deal, it won't ever be a big deal, to anyone, anywhere. 

Ultimately, the choice of what league a team should be playing in will be up to the owner. A guy starting a team in Annapolis, MD will have some entirely different options compared to the guy in Santa Barbara, CA and the guy in Santa Fe, NM. It will be up to each owner to do all the research he can on every possible option to make the best decision for his team. 

I hope this was a good, informative read for everyone that wasn't too biased. Keep your eyes open for other op-eds down the line. Feel free to comment with any topics you'd like to see covered by the Pyramid. As always, like us on Facebook and/or follow us on Twitter for all the latest news and updates. Until next time. 
Comments

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Dan Roberts
    General
    Guest Post
    Interviews
    Media Partners
    MLS
    Nik Myles
    NPSL
    PDL
    Power Rankings
    Soccer And Design
    The Soccer Heel
    TWITP
    US Open Cup 2016

    Partners

    Soccer Elf
    Non League America
    For the Love of Futbol
    ​Rabble.tv 
    ​
    Michael Taylor
    ​MeritFit.co
    LeagueApps

    Archives

    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Standings
    • Regional Leagues >
      • Gulf Coast Premier League
      • Northeast Elite Soccer League
    • East Region >
      • Connecticut >
        • Amateur Soccer League of CT
        • Connecticut Adult Soccer League
        • Connecticut Soccer League
        • Shoreline Adult Soccer League
        • Southern New England Adult Soccer League
      • Maryland >
        • Maryland Major Soccer League
        • Mason-Dixon Soccer League
        • Washington Premier League
      • Massachusetts >
        • Bay State Soccer League
        • EMWSL
        • FA 1
        • Mass State Soccer League
        • USAfrica Soccer League
      • New Hampshire >
        • New Hampshire Soccer Conference
      • New Jersey >
        • Garden State Soccer League
        • Medford Soccer Association
        • North Jersey Soccer League
      • New York >
        • Buffalo District Soccer League
        • Caribbean Cup Soccer
        • Central New York State Soccer League
        • Cosmopolitan Soccer League
        • Eastern District Soccer League
        • Long Island Soccer Football League
        • Rochester District Soccer League
        • Syracuse Soccer Association
      • Pennsylvania >
        • American Soccer League
        • Capital Area Soccer League
        • Casa Soccer League
        • Erie Soccer League
        • Harrisburg Area Women's Soccer League
        • PA West Adult Soccer
        • Philadelphia Premier Soccer League
        • USL - Pennsylvania
      • Vermont >
        • Vermont Amateur Soccer League
      • Virginia >
        • Commonwealth Soccer League
        • CVA Soccer
        • Northern Virginia Adult Soccer Association
        • Richmond Adult Soccer Association
        • Soccer Organization Charlottesville Area
    • South Region >
      • Alabama >
        • Southern Alabama Soccer Association
      • Florida >
        • APSL
        • Beaches Adult Soccer League
        • Coral Springs Men's Soccer League
        • Central Florida Soccer League
        • Florida Suncoast Soccer League
        • Gold Coast Soccer Premier League
        • Lakeland Adult Soccer Association
        • Miami Soccer League
        • NE Florida Soccer League
        • South Florida Leagues
        • Spring Gulf Coast
      • Georgia >
        • Atlanta District Adult Soccer League
      • Kentucky >
        • Mockingbird Soccer
      • North Carolina >
        • ABASA
      • Tennessee >
        • Middle Tennessee Soccer Alliance
      • Texas >
        • Austin Men's Soccer Association
        • Fort Worth Premier League
        • North Texas Premier Soccer Association
        • Texas Collegiate Soccer League
    • Midwest Region >
      • Illinois >
        • Central Illinois Soccer League
        • CLASA Soccer League
        • Metropolitan Soccer League
        • National Soccer League of Chicago
        • Premier Soccer League Chicagoland
        • Tri-County Soccer League
      • Kansas >
        • Emporia Soccer League
        • KCK Soccer League
        • Lawrence Adult Soccer League
      • Michigan >
        • Blossomland Soccer League
        • Michigan Premier Soccer League
        • Michigan United Soccer League
      • Minnesota >
        • Duluth Amateur Soccer League
        • Minnesota Adult Soccer League
        • Minnesota Recreational Soccer League
        • Southern Minnesota Adult Soccer League
      • Ohio >
        • Cincinnati Premier League
        • Columbus Premier League
        • Dayton Amateur Soccer League
        • Lake Erie Soccer League
        • Northeast Ohio Amateur Soccer Association
      • Wisconsin >
        • Northern Wisconsin Soccer League
        • Wisconsin Soccer Leagues
    • West Region >
      • Arizona >
        • Arizona Champions League
        • State United Amateur Soccer League
      • California >
        • California International Soccer Club
        • NorCal Leagues >
          • Liga Eastbay
          • Liga South Bay
          • Liga Valley
        • Peninsula Soccer League
        • San Francisco Soccer Football League
        • So Cal Premier
        • South Bay Sports
      • Colorado >
        • Colorado Premier League
      • Hawaii >
        • Major Island Soccer Association >
          • Division 1
          • Division 2
          • Division 3
      • Montana >
        • Bozeman Adult Soccer League
        • Helena Adult Soccer Association
      • New Mexico >
        • Albuquerque Soccer League
        • Mesilla Valley Soccer League
        • Santa Fe Adult Soccer League
      • Oregon >
        • Greater Portland Soccer District
        • Oregon Premier League
        • Southern Oregon Adult Soccer
      • Utah >
        • Greater Salt Lake Soccer League
        • Premier Club Soccer League
      • Washington >
        • Evergreen Premier League
        • Greater Seattle Soccer League
        • Snohomish County Adult Soccer League
        • Western Washington Premier League
    • National Leagues >
      • National Premier Soccer League
      • Premier Development League
      • United Premier Soccer League
  • Patreon
  • Patrons
  • The Network
    • Politithink
    • Ramble Sport
  • Contact AP